August 15, 2017
A picture-book adaptation of the iconic E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial. Simplified. Very.For readers who fell through the time-space fabric of earthly life after 1982, this near goo-goo rendering for the young will provide the basics, if not the poignancy and power of "alien" affection, of the famous movie. The narrative adaptation is pared down to the bone but operates fairly smoothly, while the artwork offers some fine comic scenes, such as E.T. hiding among a pile of stuffed animals and E.T.'s various disguises. All the child characters have E.T.-size eyes, and although their heads are round, they are also as exaggeratedly large in proportion to their bodies as their alien friend's. The basic plot is here, but the emphasis is on getting E.T. away from the bad guys, who don't look nearly bad enough--though when they finally catch E.T. and put him in the coffinlike box, it's pretty creepy. The flat, affect-free narration underplays the movie's take on the magic of friendship, no matter how peculiar the "other," and Elliott's gesture of love in helping his friend return home is reduced to plot points. As in the film, principal characters are white, though Smith places some people of color in background roles. OK, you've read the SparkNotes, now it is time to see the movie. (Picture book. 3-6)
COPYRIGHT(2017) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
October 1, 2017
Gr 1-3- -This uninspired adaptation of the beloved 1982 film reads like too many books that are based on a movie-all plot and no heart. The main events are all here: the boy hero Elliott finds an alien in his shed, which he lures out with candy; only the children know about the new addition to the family, E.T. the extraterrestrial; government bad guys are after E.T.; and the children are devastated when the creature must go home. The book is certainly faithful to the movie and its computer-generated images are perfectly fine, but it has none of the hilarity, magic, and heartbreak that the movie's writer, Mathison, and its director, Steven Spielberg, brought to the big screen. VERDICT Not a worthwhile purchase.- Henrietta Verma, National Information Standards Organization, Baltimore
Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
January 1, 2018
Elliott and siblings hide their new extraterrestrial friend until he can find a way home(�cf2]E.T.�cf1]). A young Dana Scully and scaredy-cat friend Fox Mulder encounter aliens while backyard camping (�cf2]X-Files�cf1]). Nostalgic parents will most enjoy these bland pop-culture picture books, a retelling of the classic eighties film and a takeoff on characters from the nineties sci-fi show. Smith's slick art cartoonishly depicts the iconic characters.
(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)